Prenuptial AgreementsIn 1981, the Michigan Legislature adopted a statute allowing for prenuptial agreements. The statute stated, “a contract relating to property made between persons in contemplation of marriage shall remain in full force after the marriage takes place.” (MCL 557.28) That being said, for many years the Michigan judiciary did not permit premarital agreements to be enforceable when it came to divorce, allowing them only to be used upon the death of a party to the marriage.

In 1991, that changed. In the court decision, Rinvelt v. Rinvelt, the court ruled a prenuptial contract is enforceable, even when it is made in contemplation of divorce.

That being said, for many years, courts found ways to escape the enforceability of a prenuptial agreement, especially when the terms of the same appeared to be harsh. Different courts found that if there was a mistake, fraud, duress or non-disclosure of a material fact, then the agreement could be avoided. Other courts found if the agreement was so one-sided, it was “unconscionable” and, therefore, unenforceable. While other courts found that when facts and circumstances had materially changed from when the agreement was entered into, enforcing the same would be unfair or unreasonable. See Reid v. Reid (2005).

Things have materially changed again based on the most recent court decision, Allard v. Allard (January 2017). In Allard, the court held that parties to a prenuptial agreement cannot abrogate the trial court’s authority to exercise its own judgment and make equitable decisions under two specific statutes: MCL 552.401 and MCL 552.23 (1).

These two statutory provisions permit a trial judge to invade one party’s separate property, i.e. property that they typically owned before the marriage or acquired during the marriage from inheritance or a gift, when to do so was called for by the judge to “do equity” in the divorce case. Typically, the judge would do this because there were insufficient assets for the suitable support and maintenance of one party, or when one party acted during the marriage to improve the separate property of the other.

When the dust settled from the Allard decision, the court ruled that the parties to a divorce action cannot, through a premarital agreement, compel a court of equity to order a property settlement that the court believes to be inequitable. Although the parties have a fundamental right to contract as they see fit, they have no right, currently under the law, to take away the court’s power to be fair and equitable to both parties, as the parties divorce. The court ruled to the extent that the parties’ prenuptial agreement attempts to limit the trial court’s equitable authority, it is necessarily void as against both statute and the public policy codified by our legislature.

The impact of the Allard decision has raised many questions within the area of family law. The first question is, what happens to existing prenuptial agreements that many attorneys previously drafted for their clients? Will any of these premarital agreements still be enforceable?

All parties to prenups, and their attorneys, should be concerned about the impact of the Allard decision. The court specifically did find that premarital agreements are enforceable, as long as they do not restrict the trial court’s authority to do equity. The Allard decision indicated that premarital agreements are helpful to the court to identify separate property owned by each party before the contemplated marriage occurs. Again, it needs to be kept in mind, that the assets that are identified as one party’s separate property coming into the marriage will not be invaded, unless equity and good conscience of the trial court judge requires doing so. A good thought process here is that when making a premarital agreement, it is important to be fair in doing so and consider changing the benefits to one party that might flow after the marriage has lasted for a longer period of time, and also to take into consideration whether it is contemplated that there may be the birth of children that occurs as a result of that marriage.

The key thing to keep in mind with premarital agreements is that assets that are accumulated or debts that are incurred during the marriage are treated differently by the court than assets that were owned by each party before the marriage. If you can view a marriage as a business partnership, all assets that are acquired or debts that are incurred after the parties say, “I do,” until the parties are divorced are treated differently. Typically, inherited assets are viewed as gifts to one party, and not the product of hard work and labor of either of the married partners. And, as long as those assets are not “co-mingled” and turned into marital assets, the court will generally keep them separate when dividing marital assets in a divorce. That being said, if a party inherits a home and then during the marriage, over the next five or 10 years, both parties work hard to refurbish the home, paint it, make alterations, etc., the court can then treat such improvements as marital improvements and award the other party, who didn’t inherit that property, a portion of the value of such improvements.

Bottom line? Premarital agreements are helpful to the court. But, per Allard, those premarital agreements cannot prevent invasion of separate property or the award of spousal support, if the court believes that the same is necessary in order to be fair and equitable, considering the length of the marriage and what the other party will receive upon dissolution of the marriage. Make sure to always consult an experienced family law attorney, well in advance of the contemplated marriage if the desire is to protect one’s separate estate from being invaded upon a divorce.

Related links:

Rinvelt v. Rinvelt:

Allard v. Allard:

Advice to save your marriage and get your Ex Boyfriend/girlfriend back contact DR DAVID @ [email protected] or WhatsApp him directly @ +1(203) 533-9214 for Urgent effective love Spell to get ex lover back or save you marriage fast and his result is 100% guarantee.  My name is MICHAEL RACHEL I am here to make a review about how Dr. DAVID helped me in fixing my marriage and also to those out there seeking for help and advice on how to save your broken marriage or relationship, few months ago I was having issues with my husband I noticed he has been having an affair with another young lady in his place of work I confronted him but he got angry and say to my face that it’s true, as if that was not enough he went ahead by telling me he doesn’t love me anymore that he wanted a divorce I was to devastated and confused, I pleaded with him that I don’t want a divorce but he insisted, before then I had heard about Dr. DAVID while browsing on the internet how he use to help people with broken marriages and relationships, I gave it a thought and I decided to contact him, he promise to put a smile on my face again, I followed his instructions and after 3days I was so surprised to see my husband kneeling before me and apologizing for what he had said about the divorce, this is something I never expected, I thank Dr. DAVID for what he has done for me, now am living happily with my husband and he has stopped seeing the other woman. Please if you are having issues like this I advice you to contact Dr. DAVID on Email : [email protected] website: WhatsApp: +2347040654140
by MICHEAL RACHEL October 10, 2021 at 09:22 PM
Hi everyone I'm Wayne Desmond Hi everyone I'm Wayne Desmond and am here to share the wonderful work Dr Believe did for me. After 5 years in marriage with my husband with 2 kids, my husband started acting weird and going out with other ladies and showed me cold love, on several occasions he threatens to divorce me if I dare question him about his affair with other ladies, I was totally devastated and confused until a old friend of mine told me about a spell caster on the internet called Dr. Believe who help people with relationship and marriage problem by the powers of love spells, at first I doubted if such thing ever exists but decided to give it a try, when I contact him, he helped me cast a love spell and within 48hours my husband came back to me and started apologizing, now he has stopped going out with other ladies and his with me for good and for real. Contact this great love spell caster for your relationship or marriage problem to be solved today via email: [email protected] or WhatsApp: +19713839183 Here is my personal email: [email protected] if you wish to ask me anything
by Wayne Desmond June 3, 2021 at 04:54 AM
I am here to spread this good news to the entire world on how Dr Emu helped me solve my infertility problem and i am so happy now that i am now a mother because for over 4 years i have been trying to get pregnant and needed help, i and my husband always go for medical check up and the doctor always say that the both of us are fine and i have nowhere else to get help from and all hope was almost lost until one day i visited a friend of mine and i told her what i was passing through and she introduce me to this great spell caster called Dr Emu who helped her when she was in need of help, so i took a try to contact Dr Emu through his email and i explain all my problem to him and after we have talked he perform an infertility spell for me and after that he told me what i should do, and i followed the instruction he gave and after that he instructed to sleep with my husband and also i followed the instruction and he said that the next week i should go for medical check up and the doctor confirmed that i was 4 months pregnant and i was so happy that all my sorrows were gone for ever, i am so very happy now and also you need any kind of help or the same line with mine, contact Dr Emu on his email: [email protected] or Call/Text his whatsapp phone number +2347012841542
by Gavin Wear December 15, 2020 at 07:45 AM
Post a Comment

Get Help Now

Fill out the form below to connect with us, and we will be in touch with you shortly to discuss your case.